It could not be true
Third day of the June heatwave in the EU.
I’m watching a popular talk show (C à vous) on France TV.
Seven well-known journalists and cultural luminaries are seated around the table. But there’s also Jancovici, a leading figure in the field of climate change (see his Shift project), who has been in the climate trenches in France for just as long as James Hansen has been in the US. Their views are similar.
Jancovici suddenly looks old. He has probably spent several nights sleeping poorly. The others don’t look fresh either. When he says, "So this is it", I see seven faces staring intently at him with crestfallen expressions. As if, with a single blow, he’s rammed their awareness of the future into an thoroughly grim corner.
Jancovici takes his time. Perhaps he wants to let them pick themselves up a bit first. Then: "No, it can’t be undone either. We are facing centuries of climate misery that may be even worse than this heatwave." Some slump back in their chairs. A woman asks: "Adaptation, then?" Janco sees no possibilities.
Someone commented on this moment during that show with: "I literally fell off my chair laughing when I saw the look on the journalists' faces as they realized there was nothing to be done about it".
Notice how, in human cognition, mental images of possible future circumstances (like climate heating) − as long as they are visualized in the brain within a range of other possible circumstances and developments − do not at all come across as real; they are not experienced or felt as real. This is a human weakness, perhaps especially so for people today, since they navigate increasingly virtual (conceived, artificial) worlds that are entirely saturated with − and built from − words and images. In fact, these are all mere references rather than actual objects and processes that bite, push, hit, and take on undeniable forms.. And so: Circumstances must be thrust in people's face before they can truly be assessed. In short, the proof is only in the pudding.
What are we actually seeing unfold in that talk show?
A conversation in which the horrifying incomprehensibility of the truth about climate change launches itself, like a seagull with powerful wingbeats, out of the narrow frame of ordinary human worries and into consciousness. A consciousness within a human mind that has evolved over millennia in the comfortable cradle of stable climate patterns, making their rhythm its home. That this cradle could be scorched. No way!! From the very beginning, that mind has whispered: ‘It can not be true’. Just to keep from going mad. But then there comes a moment when that gentle whisper is unmasked. Crushing.
But don't worry, that won't last long. Because the human stronghold against ungraspable facts has more tricks up its sleeve. Dismissing something using labels, for example. Call it “alarmism” or “El Niño” and you won't have to give it a second thought for the time being.
Unfortunately, global warming is performing ever more horrific acts on the world stage, putting that stronghold under ever-greater fire and driving its defenders out of their minds. And so we see more and more weapons being deployed to contain the rising craziness surrounding the impossible truth of global warming. Such as:
- Consulting and believing fortune-tellers, spiritual healers, Bibles, prophets and dreamers. This category encompasses all kinds of exotic stuff. For example, the theories that climate sceptics dig up and proclaim (such as Creative Society), conspiracy theories, the increasing tendency among evangelists to place global warming within end-times prophecies (the Second Coming of Jesus Christ), and also the visions of the future put forward by prominent business moguls (such as P. Marshall) and some scientific institutes (such as Heartland).
- Plunging into an intense craving for superpowers and super-solutions. This impulse has fueled the recent absurd investments in AI and the accompanying dreams of a future offering analyses and syntheses that could potentially transcend human capabilities. Underneath it all, one can actually hear the cry for help from mankind in extreme mental distress.
- Exploring and envisioning absurd escape routes − such as searching for habitable planets elsewhere or relocating to Mars and the Moon. I see the SpaceX hype (floating on a handful of wild, cobbled-together promises) and the recent massive investments in lunar expeditions by various nations as stemming from this.
- Trying to circumvent the grim reality of climate change with money. This includes the recent wave of funding from large investors for countless start-ups aimed at making geo-engineering solutions applicable on a large scale (see Stardust) − potentially bypassing governments and regulations.
A brighter light in the darkness
And how, then, should we assess two recently published, rather radical policy roadmaps aimed at bringing global warming under control in the long term? I am referring to
- on the one hand, the Global Justice Report (a plan for equality and prosperity within planetary boundaries) by the World Inequality Lab (Picketty et al.),
- and, on the other hand, the Roadmap for Eradicating Poverty Beyond Growth by the UN Special Rapporteur to the UN Human Rights Council, which aims to develop a comprehensive set of policy proposals – the Roadmap – to guide governments and international organisations in implementing policies that prioritise human rights and well-being over growth in gross domestic product (GDP).
Are they also part of that stronghold?
No, more like a desperate leap off that stronghold i.e. two attempts to land with both feet firmly on the floor of reality.
In both plans, I see a kind of anger coming to a head against the recently hardening liberal capitalism that has severely frustrated (and blocked) climate policy and has proven inherently incapable of removing a major stumbling block to it: namely national and international inequality.
- Within the Picketty group, this anger is steaming on 10 years of campaigning against the insatiability of the super-rich, as well as on the historical French aversion (which still remains strong in socialist and communist circles) to the North American ‘winner-takes-it-all’ mentality.
- And within the Roadmap group, that anger is fueled by the disillusionment of the human rights movement and the labour movement, both of which traditionally sought governments rooted in socialism. Their actual ambitions were quite radically thwarted by the flare-up of liberalism (and privatisation) in recent decades. But within the weakened UN − and supported there by the many socialist-leaning governments from the poverty belt − they are now able to deliver a united uppercut to the wealthy global elite.
What both analyses have in common is that they take an extremely critical stance towards the hugely dominant control (in terms of orientation and design) exercised over the global economy by private-sector decision-makers. Piketty’s main message: ‘We cannot continue to row towards our doom as galley slaves of the rich.’
A breath of fresh air
The Piketty group takes a bold approach by proposing the creation of a central governing body (Global Justice Platform) responsible for (a) generating sufficient revenue via global wealth and income taxes, (b) managing a World Sovereign Fund that accumulates approximately 10 per cent of the world’s capital stock, and (c) distributing country dividends allocated to each country on the basis of equal per capita amounts, to be used to finance climate investments, education and healthcare. Once the fund has been built up, the income from those assets will gradually replace tax revenue as the platform’s main source of funding. To put it somewhat cynically: the group is siphoning off vast amounts of capital from the billionaires, and is then using that money to play a part in the economy. So they are going to play the capital game − with its profit-grabbing, its competition, its continuous innovation − while counting on continuous productivity growth (= automation, robotisation, upscaling and globalisation) to drastically reduce material labour input (industrial and food production) on a global scale in the long term, whilst drastically increasing immaterial productions (such as education and healthcare).
The Roadmap group goes even further than the Piketty group in terms of tightening and strengthening public governance, thereby dismantling private capital control. In short: they want to completely eliminate the power of shareholders and replace it with representatives of social and solidarity-based organisations and groups (such as co-operatives, associations, mutual societies, foundations, self-help groups and other entities that act in accordance with the values and principles of the social and solidarity economy), while also equipping public authorities to steer and monitor economic processes in a much more interventionist and rigorous manner: "States ensure at least minimum essential levels of the rights to food, health, housing, education, and social security. These are not soft aspirations; they are justiciable legal constraints that structure the legitimate space for macroeconomic choice". Behold the ‘human rights’ economy they advocate. They are quite optimistic about this restructuring of governance, because they argue that (zie §171 en §172 op pagina 74):
"Governments may seem powerless, but in times of crisis they have always managed to spring into action and take matters into their own hands. Moreover, most of the tools already exist in a rudimentary form. They simply need to be modernised and strengthened. It is not a question of reinventing the wheel, but of building on these precedents, linking them together and institutionalising them as mutually reinforcing components of a human rights-based economy that is no longer dependent on growth."
Can we curb climate runaway with these plans?
No, I don’t think so. Their main shortcoming: A lack of proper understanding of the rapid deterioration of the climate. Stabilising at 2 degrees of warming, as the Piketty group envisages, is an illusion. Above 1.5 degrees, the climate will spiral out of control unless we reach net-zero within a few years. All sorts of accelerating processes – such as the degradation of carbon sinks and the emergence of new sources – will send your carbon budget plummeting. Climate misery will hit much harder than they project. In particular, carbon-absorbing systems (such as forests and oceans) are deteriorating rapidly. Furthermore, the thawing of the permafrost is adding fuel to the fire, as are the additional emissions caused by the massive increase in adaptation measures and reactions such as upgrading water supply systems, air conditioning, coastal defences, migration, accelerated electrification, and so on. Neither plan adequately captures the scale of this short-term emergency. We need to slam on the brakes much harder.
On 27 June, F. Otto, a member of the WWA-team, summarised that truth rather concisely: "Yes it’s climate change, yes it’s us, no it’s not El Niño. Simply put, we remain on a one-way trip towards a more dangerous future, and it’s time we hit the brakes.”
Are the stones these two plans throw into the proverbial henhouse big enough?
Yes, I think so. The direction, in particular, is excellent. It radically opens up the discussion on ways to overcome the hurdle of inequality (see also the time factor in Stegeman’s article) and breathes new life into it. That’s invaluable for collectively grasping the fundamental anxieties surrounding the seemingly impossible reality of global warming. But that discussion is of no use if we end up in the afterlife before it can coordinate our actions. We need to accelerate our mobilization and decisiveness if we are to avert the truly catastrophic unleashing of global warming in the near future and stabilise the climate in the long term. That said, these two masterpieces are an excellent stimulus for that acceleration.
Jac Nijssen, 2026
This article has been written July 2026.
A Dutch version is published on duurzaamnieuws.nl since 5 July 2026.